I don't know nothing that stinks as bad as an old dog. Both Lennie and Candy's dog would suffer if they lived. Counterfeit apparel and accessories are available in many cities at far lower prices than the authentic merchandise. How Did Critics React to Of Mice and Men? Renew your subscription to regain access to all of our exclusive, ad-free study tools. Here is a video that describes Candy's character in-depth: Often when groups of the same gender live in close quarters with one another, there is a "pecking order" established; that is, the strongest--whether it be physical or mental dominance--is at the top, and the weakest at the bottom. He relentlessly pursues the dogs death, more for his own comfort than to put the dog out of its misery. Candy is introduced in the start of chapter two, he is described indirectly by the narrator as a Stoop shouldered old man(Steinbeck 18). She loved that dog more than anything and couldn't believe that Carlson would do something like that. Candys dog symbolizes these realities and fears in the farm workers life. Discount, Discount Code Carlsons view of Candys dog also hints at the humanity of putting the dog out of its misery, something they couldnt do for an old man like Candy. The following questions and answers are taken from the eNotes Study Guide to Of Mice and Men . Throughout the fight there are many animals references referring to either Lennie or Curley. When Curley comes into the bunkhouse, for whom is he looking? He thinks that Slim is with his wife. Want 100 or more? The dog is unable to do anything for itself and Candy is struggling to care for it, meaning that Carlson may have thought that it would be better for everyone if the animal was put down. Free trial is available to new customers only. You'll also receive an email with the link. After Carlsons many pushes to have Candy shoot his old dog, Slim, the skinner, whose opinions were law, speaks up and agrees with Carlson, encouraging Candy to accept the old dogs fate. What are Candys reasons for not wanting to shoot the dog? "Hes all stiff with rheumatism. The next day he has no dog, and when the other guys go out to the field he has nobody to comfort him. Stinks like hell, too. While Candys dog may be old and useless now, Candy doesnt want to let go of their connection and the good times they shared when he herded sheep with him.. That dog of Candys is so God damn old he cant hardly walk. I'llI'll smash 'em with a stick" (p. 58). Though the pet was once the best damn sheep dog as Candy states, it was put out once it stopped being productive. He was killed with far greater compassion though., Carlson killing Candys dog leaves Candy wishing hed done it himself, whereas when George killed Lennie, he isnt left with guilt. He aint no good to you, Candy. At the end of the novel, George kills Lennie in much the same way as Carlson kills Candys dog. I won't have no place to go, an' I can't get no more jobs.(Steinbeck, 60) This quote really symbolizes the suffering that Candy goes through and how the men were willing to kill the old dog, while letting the old guy suffer. He says that they will be taken care of and Lennie will be protected, What do George and Lennie talk about when Lennie comes into the house? The ending puts a "frame" around the story. $24.99 Additionally, Candy looks desperate when the outlook of being part of Lennie and George's dream of the small farm comes up, he says, "And they give me two hundred and fifty dollars 'cause I lost my hand. Candy says, I dont mind takin care of him. (45)., Soon after they arrive at the ranch, George and Lennie meet some new and delightful people that they will be living with, until they earn enough money to buy a place of their own. Carlson goes on to elaborate on the dog's smell stating that he can tells the dog has been in the bunk house for days after because the bunk house stinks for two to three days. Latest answer posted August 09, 2017 at 8:49:59 AM. Unfortunately, one day Carlson decided to take Candy's dog for a walk and he got loose. creating and saving your own notes as you read. TO CANCEL YOUR SUBSCRIPTION AND AVOID BEING CHARGED, YOU MUST CANCEL BEFORE THE END OF THE FREE TRIAL PERIOD. Why does Carlson want to shoot Candy's dog? Why does Carlson want to shoot Candy's dog? on 50-99 accounts. Curley has accused Slim of eying his wife, a charge which Slim and the others laugh off. Accessed 1 May 2023. Who are the experts?Our certified Educators are real professors, teachers, and scholars who use their academic expertise to tackle your toughest questions. First, Carlson states that the dog is so old that it cannot walk any longer. You can argue that his reasons are partly good and partly just selfish and mean. Why does Candy say that he should have shot his dog himself instead of letting a stranger do it? The killing of Candys dog foreshadows Lennies death. A flophouse The dog was old, sick, and in pain, and Carlson believes that George did it to put the dog out of its misery. Use up and down arrows to review and enter to select. Candy says that he should have shot the dog, and that "you shoot your own dog.". Whatever Carlson's reasons for shooting Candy's dog, it is clear that he did it with the best of intentions. Carlson takes the dog outside, promising Slim that he will bury the corpse. Why does Candy say that he should have shot his dog himself instead of letting a stranger do it? The other men are not scared of Curley. The main reason why Carlsons killing of Candys dog was justified is because the old dog was well past its years and of no use to anyone. How is Lennie different from the other men? How are Lennie's actions similar to the events that happened earlier when Lennie and George were. Explain the following passage and its function in the story: Foreshadowing leading up to what could possibly happen( since there was conflict between curley's wife and the men. He doesnt like Candys dog because he smells bad and is too old to do anyone any good; he tells Candy to shoot the dog. Look CandyThis ol dog jus suffers himself all the time. By the time Lennie finally relaxes his grip, Curley's hand has been ruined. How does that seem, given, The dog ( represents George and Lennie's friendship ) is all that he has and grew up with. John Steinbeck and Of Mice and Men Background. What do Slim and Whit discover in a pulp magazine? In Of Mice and Men, how does Candy become involved in George and Lennie's "dream ranch". Another possibility is that Carlson may have had it out for Candy personally and saw shooting his dog as a way to get back at him. Why does Carlson want to shoot Candy's dog? Already a member? ( Numerous Biblical stories could run parallel here. In order to kill Lennie, George would need a gun. How is this important for the group of men? Describe the conversation George and Lennie have after the men go in search of a fight between Cruley and Slim. Why do dogs lay down when they see another dog? Reads 1.5K. First, the dog is stiff with rheumatism. Second, Carlson says that the dog is no good for Candy. He wants to keep his hand soft for his wife. for a group? He is an old man that is missing a hand. Log in here. Related Read: Why does my dog cry when he sees other dogs? "That stink hangs around even after hes gone." Best summary PDF, themes, and quotes. A ranch workers life during this time period was determined by his usefulness, and survival was directly linked to his ability to physically work. Why do you think the author spends so much of the narration talking about what a kind person Lennie is? Wanting the best for his dog, Candy allows Carlson to kill him. I wisht somebodyd shoot me if I got old an a cripple, Slim presents an important symbolism behind Candys old dog. In the world Of Mice and Men describes, Candys dog represents the fate awaiting anyone who has outlived his or her purpose. nous utilisons les cookies afin de personnaliser le contenu et les publicits, de fournir des fonctionnalits pour les rseaux sociaux et analyser notre traffic. You can have a pup if you want to. He seemed to shake himself free for speech. Since George sees the pain and suffering Candy goes through after he expresses that he oughtta shot that dog [himself] shouldnt oughtta of let no stranger shoot [his] dog (), George takes matters into his own hands when the entire ranch is out to kill Lennie. Carlson shot Candys dog to put it out of its misery because Candy couldnt bring himself to do it. Lennie scares the girl in the red dress in the town of Weed. Carlson wants to shoot Candy's old dog because it irritates him. An he aint no good to himself. The other ranch hands felt conflicted about Carlson shooting Candy's dog. He wants to be, Candy is lonely because of his old age. The guys leaves him back at the ranch while they go to drink and sleep with women. The closest thing to friendship Candy possessed was the bond him and his dog shared. eNotes.com will help you with any book or any question. Why is the man in the magazine? The guys leaves him back at the ranch while they go to drink and sleep with women. Second, Carlson says that the dog is no goodfor Candy. At the same time, the concept of shooting something to save it from a miserable life foreshadows the tragic events that will unfold between George and Lennie at the end of the story. This event is a clear indication of Carlson's personality, and it is one of the reasons why he is not a likable character. He can't chew nothing else", and Hes all stiff with rheumatism. In the end, Candy is isolated due to his age and disability., An aging ranch handyman, Candy lost his hand in an accident and worries about his future on the ranch. 61). Both of these instances where Carlson kills Candys dog and George kills Lennie, supports the theme of loyalty and friendship. I wisht somebodyd shoot me if I got old an a cripple, Slim presents an important symbolism behind Candys old dog. FOUND ON http://www.easynotecards.com/notecard_set/2232. What is Carlsons solution to the problem presented by the dog? Members will be prompted to log in or create an account to redeem their group membership. Because of his condition, he is unable to work alongside the other men and in turn feels lonely with only his dog to accompany him which is later euthanized as a result of, [Candy] said miserably, "You seen what they done to my dog tonight? Later, in chapter three, Carlson gives two more reasons why the dog should be put down. Accessed 1 May 2023. Who are the experts?Our certified Educators are real professors, teachers, and scholars who use their academic expertise to tackle your toughest questions. He had his broom in his hand. "Carl's right, Candy. However, their attempt to stop Carlson shows that they are not like him. What happens as a result of Lennie's taking care of himself? This shows that he is lonely because when his dog dies he losses his only friend. He didn't expect to end up doing back-breaking farm labor for room and board plus fifty dollars a month in wages. If George tried to cut Lennie's throat it would be too gruesome, and he might fail in the attempt. Was Carlson killing Candys dog justified? Related Read: Can you bring your dog to lazy dog? Worked here about three months ago?". The dog is seen as useless and smelly, therefore it was seen as more of a nuisance to Carlson and the others in the bunk house. First of all, he says that the dog . By the way he acts towards other characters in the novella. When Carlson shoots Candy's dog, George learns how to kill quickly and painlessly with a pistol. What are Carlsons reasons for shooting Candys dog How could this incident foreshadow possible events to come? One of the new people that Lennie and George meet was Candy and his old dog. What is Carlsons problem and what does he tell Candy to do? His hand is cut off, so he can't lift stuff. Wellhell! Through these characters, Steinbeck helps the reader understand the stereotype of the uselessness of the elderly and disabled. They says he wasn't no good to himself nor nobody else(Steinbeck 60). Our summaries and analyses are written by experts, and your questions are answered by real teachers. Lifelong companions that provide hope. Look at several garments in different price ranges in a store. As Carlson describes Candy's dog as "so God damn old he can't hardly walk" and that he " [s]tinks like hell, too," Carlson is trying to convince Slim to agree with him and persuade "Candy to shoot his old dog.". The author needed to establish that George had access Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Carlson laughed. Fifth, the dog can no longer eat solid food; Candy gives the dog milk. After Carlsons many pushes to have Candy shoot his old dog, Slim, the skinner, whose opinions were law, speaks up and agrees with Carlson, encouraging Candy to accept the old dogs fate. for a customized plan. Carlson doesn't have a good reason; he's just a mean guy. Use the phrases below to write complete sentences about what you and your friends do every Saturday. Got no teeth, damn near blind, cant eat.[]. You'll also receive an email with the link. They find Steinbeck's portrayal of Lennie excessively sentimental. His dog enters later in chapter two, whom is described as a dragfooted sheepdog, gray of a muzzle, and with pale, old eyes(Steinbeck 26). Save over 50% with a SparkNotes PLUS Annual Plan! I wont have no place to go, an I cant get no more jobs. Your group members can use the joining link below to redeem their group membership. Carlson eventually takes the dog out of the room and shoots it; Candy does not try to stop him, he just sits there looking up at the ceiling, he doesn't do anything, because slim agrees with Carlson that he should shoot it and Slim agreed to give Candy one of his puppies. We're sorry, SparkNotes Plus isn't available in your country. He believed that he was doing the right thing for the animal, and while Candy may have initially been hesitant, he ultimately agreed with Carlson's decision. Along with this, Candy and his dog create a parallel with George and Lennie., Candy is isolated after the loss of his hand since he is no longer able to work in the field with the other men. Educators go through a rigorous application process, and every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team. Carlson is a bitter man. Carlson's footsteps died away. For the next 7 days, you'll have access to awesome PLUS stuff like AP English test prep, No Fear Shakespeare translations and audio, a note-taking tool, personalized dashboard, & much more! Dont have an account? He is a terrible person and Candy's dog deserved better. Continuing to protect him, George made sure Lennie had no pain while killing him. ), Where does Whit invite George and Lennie to go? Candy's only companion was his dog, a dog he says used to be a great sheepherder in its day, a dog of which he had raised from a pup. Candy feeds him milk. I had him so long. Related Read: Does lazy dog have a dog menu? How does candy react when Carlson brings the old dog outside? Why does Carlson want to shoot Candy's dog? You're yella as a frog belly. Carlson believes the dog is too old and decrepit to be of any use Whit enters the bunkhouse with a magazine featuring a man he used to work with. George agrees and with Candy's investment, which is half the cost of the ranch George described, the dream becomes more tangible. What is the relationship between Candy and his dog? In "Of Mice and Men", Carlson shoots Candy's old, disabled dog because he believes that it is the humane thing to do. What do we learn about Curley's relationship with his wife, based on this event? Carlson is a heartless person who doesn't care about anyone but himself. When they arrive at the ranch, Lennie and George meet Candy and his elderly dog as they are introduced to the others in the bunkhouse. What differences do you see? Carlson gives three of main reasons for wanting Candy's dog shot. to start your free trial of SparkNotes Plus. Your subscription will continue automatically once the free trial period is over. These characters try to stop Carlson from shooting the dog, but they are not successful. And physically Lennie survives with George, Because Lennie is bigger than him and he picks fights with bigger people. (one code per order). After Carlson shot her dog, Candy was understandably upset. Carlson says the dog "ain't no good" to Candy, unable to see that the dog still has value as Candy's friend and companion.
Mcgloin Hall Creighton,
Angelito Antonio Technique,
Ealing Trailfinders Players,
Articles W
